My Surprising Experiment With Peer-to-Peer Lending

Marc Lichtenfeld
by Marc Lichtenfeld, Chief Income Strategist, The Oxford Club
peer to peer income investing 0

Editor’s Note: This piece originally ran in February in our sister publication, Wealthy Retirement. You can go here to subscribe if you haven't already. It's free.

Last year, I wrote an article in The Oxford Income Letter that resulted in a flood of emails and questions - and those emails are still coming in today.

People are hearing more about peer-to-peer lending and are curious about whether they should get in on the action.

It’s not surprising, considering that you can make 6% or more lending money to individual borrowers.

But don’t worry, you don’t have to become a loan shark. There’s a way to “put money on the street” without hiring a goon to be your enforcer...

There are several internet platforms where you can deposit money and select which borrowers you’d like to lend to.

You don’t get personal information about the borrower. Rather, you’ll see something that looks like this...

peer to peer income investing 1

peer to peer income investing 2

This listing is from Prosper, one of the largest peer-to-peer lending sites. The borrower from North Carolina is seeking an $8,000 loan for debt consolidation.

The nice thing about peer-to-peer lending sites is that they allow a group of people to lend money to a borrower. One individual doesn’t have to come up with $8,000.

This was a loan I funded, along with many other people, with just $25.

Prosper rates this borrower “AA,” its highest rating. It takes into account the borrower’s credit score, income and other information that any other lender would consider. As the actual lenders, however, we don’t see all of that detailed information, just a range.

You can see that this borrower’s FICO score is 680-699, their income is between $75,000 and $99,999, and other details that will help you decide if you want to lend to them.

Prosper and the other peer-to-peer platforms rate their borrowers according to these variables. The higher the rating, the lower interest rate they will pay.

In this case, the borrower has Prosper’s highest rating and is paying about 6%. Someone with the lowest rating may pay as much as 35% per year.

For the lender, 35% may be very attractive, but the risk of default is much higher.

Will I Get My Money Back?

Like any loan you’d make to a friend or brother-in-law, you get your money back only if they repay the loan. Peer-to-peer platforms generally don’t do a good job of retrieving your money if the borrower stops paying.

They’ll send it into collections and try to recover your money, but good luck. You’ll probably never see it again.

That being said, a default here hurts the borrower’s credit rating like any other default.

As with other loans, each month, the borrower pays back interest and principal. He sends in one payment, and Prosper divvies up the funds among the lenders.

I funded the listing above in October with $25. So far, I’ve been paid back $2.57.

I’ve had two types of experiences with Prosper.

Between 2006 and 2008, I funded 19 loans. Because that period was in the middle of the financial crisis, five loans defaulted, four of which were discharged in bankruptcy.

Due to the defaults, and after collecting interest on all the loans, I essentially broke even over those few years.

As part of an experiment for The Oxford Income Letter, I reopened my account with $500 in September. I have made 21 loans of $25 each (the last loan was made with interest that I earned). So far, so good. None have defaulted or are late, but it’s been only a short period of time.

In the five months the account has been open, I’ve earned 12% on my money, which is great. But I am expecting a few defaults to lower the total.

Of my 21 loans, 15 are rated A or AA - the highest and most conservative ratings. The others are very low rated and have huge interest rates. These will help me try to juice the returns - but again, the likelihood of default is much higher.

Other peer-to-peer lenders include Lending ClubUpstart and Funding Circle. There are also services, like LendingRobot (which I use), that automatically select loans for you based on your risk parameters and objectives.

Peer-to-peer lending is a fun way to generate some strong yields. But be careful, and remember that the higher the yield, the higher the risk.

If you’ve done peer-to-peer lending, let me know how it went by leaving a comment.

Good investing,


Thoughts on this article? Leave a comment below.

Add This Serial Dividend Raiser to Your Portfolio Today

Marc is an expert investor in dividend stocks. He knows how to identify companies that have always raised their payouts over time... and always will.

He calls them, fittingly enough, “Perpetual Dividend Raisers.” And they’ve made his Oxford Income Letter subscribers incredible returns over the years.

One of the most lucrative Perpetual Dividend Raisers is W.P. Carey (NYSE: WPC).

Here’s Marc checking on the pick back in April:

W.P. Carey has been in our Compound Income Portfolio and Instant Income Portfolio for several years. It pays a 6.3% yield, which is nice. But even better, it raises its dividend every quarter.

The company has increased its dividend for an incredible 53 quarters in a row, excluding special dividends. During that period, its dividend has grown at an annual rate of a little less than 7%... more than enough to outpace inflation.

It’s also raised its dividend every year since 1999.

W.P. Carey is a real estate investment trust that owns 903 commercial properties around the U.S. and Europe. Its occupancy rate is 99.1%, meaning that less than 1% of its properties are vacant. Its average lease lasts more than nine years.

Thirty percent of the company’s properties are industrial facilities, 25% are office spaces, followed by retail, self-storage, warehouses and others.

It rents space to a variety of businesses across multiple industries, including movie theaters and retailers. Its largest client is Hellweg, a chain of home improvement stores in Germany.

In 2016, W.P. Carey generated $5.12 per share in adjusted funds from operations (AFFO), a measure of cash flow for REITs. It paid out $3.93 per share for a payout ratio of 77%.

In other words, for every $1 in cash flow that was generated, W.P. Carey paid out $0.77.

W.P. Carey is a stable dividend grower that’s lifted its payout every quarter for more than 13 years and every year for nearly two decades.

If you own the stock, continue to hold. If you don’t yet own W.P. Carey, add it to your Instant Income Portfolio or Compound Income Portfolio today.

- Samuel Taube with Marc Lichtenfeld

Live Twitter Feed