Why Most Investment Systems Simply Won’t Work
by Alexander Green, Advisory Panelist
Friday, August 14, 2009: Issue #1066
Early in my 16-year career on Wall Street, I made an astonishing discovery: The overwhelming majority of my colleagues – bright, educated, experienced, and articulate – didn’t have the foggiest idea what they were talking about.
This only became obvious in retrospect, when I saw how their carefully constructed financial theories, forecasts and investment systems turned to dust rather than generating any significant profits.
(You’d be surprised to learn, for example, how many investment “pros” lose a substantial percentage of their own money in the market each year.)
The truth is that there are virtually limitless ways to take a beating in stocks – and only a few methods that work well over time. These methods are generally codified into widely accepted investment principles, something we try to emphasize here at Investment U.
I was fortunate to realize this early in my career, although it still stings to remember the chunk of change I lost 25 years ago buying my own firm’s “Strong Buy” recommendations.
Investment Systems & Harry Browne
However, things finally began to turn around for me the day I read a book – now sadly out of print – by Harry Browne called “Why the Best Laid Investment Plans Usually Go Wrong.”
(I loved the title, but Harry, who ran for President twice on the Libertarian ticket, once told me he regretted the choice. “Too negative,” his publisher told him.)
Browne argued that the odds are stacked against the typical investor who is overwhelmed by Wall Street’s technical jargon, market volatility and the business of money management. (Read the investment classic “Where Are the Customers’ Yachts?” for details.)
There are exceptions, of course, but the nation’s brokerage firms are filled with well-dressed, smart-sounding individuals spouting a lot of self-serving nonsense. As Vanguard founder John Bogle once remarked, “It’s amazing what a man doesn’t understand when he’s paid a small fortune not to understand it.”
The overwhelming majority of economic theories, market forecasts, trading strategies, investment systems, hot tips and sure-fire speculations never pan out.
Following the Wisdom of History’s Greatest Investors
Fortunately, we have the accumulated wisdom of the history’s greatest investors to guide us. I’m talking about people like Warren Buffett, Peter Lynch and John Templeton, men whose audited track records speak for themselves.
Even though these individuals used very different approaches, they agreed that in the end there is only one thing that dictates where a stock will go: earnings.
Earnings are the net profits of a business. They are what drive share prices.
- I challenge you to find a single company that increased its earnings quarter after quarter, year after year, and the stock didn’t tag along.
- Conversely, try to identify a single company whose earnings declined quarter after quarter, year after year, and the stock advanced anyway. It just doesn’t happen, even in a rip-roaring bull market.
The reason is simple. A share of stock is not a lottery ticket. It’s part ownership of a business. And profits (earnings) determine what a company is worth.
The Correlation of Earnings vs. Stock Movement
Although there are always bumps along the way, you’ll find there is a near perfect correlation between a company’s growth in earnings per share and the movement of its stock from year to year.
So forget all the mumbo-jumbo about market breadth, trading volume, put-to-call ratios, short interest, mutual fund inflows, advance/decline numbers and other market trivia.
And instead remember: share prices follow earnings. Period.
Stamp that on your forehead – act on it – and you’ll be using the one tried and true investment system that has always paid off in the end.
True, the earnings at most companies are poor right now due to the severity of the recession. But there are plenty of companies in food, pharmaceuticals, health care services, medical technology, defense contracting, gold mining and other recession-resistant industries that are still making money hand over fist.
Those are exactly the companies you ought to be buying now.
Good investing,
Alex
Alexander Green is the Investment Director of The Oxford Club, and The Insider Alert, a premium service that takes advantage of the best buy signals in the markets today. Research shows that sound companies with widespread insider buying tend to outperform the market by a substantial margin. If you’d like to find out more, you can read on here.
Today’s Investment U Crib Sheet
The Oxford Club has been following time-tested investment strategies – like following earnings -and giving Investment U readers actionable advice like this for years.
Recently Alex highlighted these advantages and “The Best, Low-Cost, Tax Efficient Investment System,” and while we’re on the topic of earnings announcements. We’ve also touched on “Understanding Earnings Surprises,” and what investors should be looking for – and looking out for – when earnings are announced.
Take a look at some of our other recent articles:
Here are some of the last few articles only found on InvestmentU.com:
- FLIR Systems, Inc. (Nasdaq: FLIR): Stock of the Day
- The Permanent Portfolio Fund: Harry Browne’s “Peace of Mind” Investment
- Tracking Insider Trading: How to Pick a Winner in a Down Market
|
The Single Best Investment for 2009
Forget another stimulus package. Or retreating into "safe-havens" like cash and gold. All you need in 2009 is a small exposure to the "secret" White Cap Index.
It's up as much as 171% straight through Wall Street's meltdown. And one of the latest stocks to be added - an Internet-related venture capital company - is up over 100% since its inclusion into the Index.
Just weeks from now, we'll add another White Cap stock to this market-trouncing index. To get a sneak peek, click here for full details.
3 Responses to “Why Most Investment Systems Simply Won’t Work”
Comments
**By submitting your comment you agree to adhere to our Comment Policy and Privacy Policy.Check out our selection of daily Investment Research:
 |
 |
Investment U RSS Feed
August 14th, 2009 at 12:15 pm
I wholly agree with Alexander Green’s comments above. The practical problem is how an individual investor like myself can determine if the reported profit numbers are true, or contrived as were those of Enron and MCI WorldCom before the truth, or rather the lack thereof, came out to the general public.
Reply
August 14th, 2009 at 2:05 pm
I wish it were as simple as finding stocks with growing earnings but it’s not.
Take Wal-Mart for example…from 2000 earnings have almost tripled (from 1.25 to 3.42) however the stock has gone no where and is in fact down almost 10% point to point.
Big disappointment for those following your earnings growth maxim.
Trade what you see not what you think.
Reply
August 14th, 2009 at 3:44 pm
My holdings all pay good dividends, and are all purchased in the same dollar amount. I can skim the day’s closing prices & instantly identify those to watch for taking a profit – or sell to minimize loss.
I would appreciate mid-monthly recommendations of high dividend-paying funds, in addition to those in the Perpetual Income Portfolio. I’m especially interested in global & natural resource funds, as well as preferred stock funds.
Your sound advice has simplified my investment procedures, & minimized anxiety. I’m a senior, enjoying your newsletter & updates!
CLH
Reply