Sir Isaac Newton On Today’s Oil Market…
by Alexander Green, Chairman, Investment U
Investment Director, The Oxford Club
Tuesday, June 17, 2008: Issue # 808
Nearly two months ago I wrote a column asking “Is the Oil Market Becoming the ‘Mother of All Bubbles?’” Personally, I don’t think it is. Even though oil has since hit several new records, some bubbles are just hard to beat.
In 1720, an English firm – the South Sea Company – was granted a monopoly to trade with South America under a treaty with Spain. The primary product? West Africans sold into slavery. This seemed like such a good deal – even though the company made little actual profit – that shares rose more than ten-fold in a single year.
When Sir Isaac Newton was asked how high South Sea stock might eventually go, he replied, “I can calculate the motion of heavenly bodies, but not the madness of people.” Good answer. The stock soon collapsed and thousands of investors were wiped out.
With this classic bubble in mind, let’s take a dispassionate look at today’s oil market.
Oil Demand Down 2% in the U.S.
Oil demand in the United States is actually down 2% so far this year. According to the federal Energy Information Administration, high oil prices and a weak economy will knock down U.S. oil consumption by 90,000 barrels a day in 2008.
The situation is similar in other parts of the world:
- The International Energy Agency (IEA), the Paris-based energy watchdog of the world’s richest nations, recently lowered its forecast for world oil demand growth by 460,000 barrels a day.
- The IEA also sees supply from outside OPEC growing by 815,000 barrels a day, the strongest growth since 2004.
- And this was before Saudi Arabia’s recent promise to boost production by a million barrels a day.
Yet despite these decidedly bearish developments for the oil market, the price is up 51% since January 1 – and more than 700% since trading at $17.45 a barrel in November 2001.
A Justified Price Rise in the Oil Market
Some will argue that this price rise within the oil market is fully justified. After all, most of the world’s major oil deposits have already been discovered. The low-hanging fruit has been picked. The remaining oil supplies are tough to get at – and expensive to recover.
Meanwhile, the world’s demand for oil keeps rising as more people around the globe – especially in emerging giants like India and China – pound the table for “more juice.”
This story is essentially correct. But it is just a story – and a thoroughly well-known one at that. It is not a rationale to buy crude oil today.
Especially since high prices always sow the seeds of their own collapse. Consumers start to conserve. Producers search for oil that was once too costly to extract. Supply and demand come back into balance.
According to Stephen Schork, President of Schork Group, a firm that advises the Organization of Petroleum Exporting Countries, “There’s nothing different between this mania, the dot-com mania, the real estate mania, the Dow Jones mania of the 1920s, the South Sea bubble and the Dutch tulip-bulb mania. History repeats itself over and over and over again.”
Speculative Fear Grips The Oil Market
Yes, speculative fever has gripped the oil market. This bull is likely to end up just like those in the ring in Mexico City. Current oil prices are simply unsustainable.
That doesn’t mean that oil is going to plunge today or tomorrow. Indeed, it could keep rising for quite some time. After all, you cannot make a rational judgment about when irrational behavior will end.
But oil prices will come back down. And that will be positive for both the economy and the stock market.
If you have big profits in your energy stocks, consider paring back. Or at least running your trailing stops closer to better protect your profits.
Charting the Oil Market Bubble
If you’re skeptical, take a look at the table below that charts the oil market bubble alongside the housing and Internet bubbles. The parallels are uncanny.
{Source Bespoke Investment Group, LLC}
Of course, history never repeats itself exactly the same way. We may not be at the exact inflection point.
But ask yourself this: If Isaac Newton were around, would he be buying into the oil market today?
Think about that. And govern yourself accordingly.
Good investing,
Alex
Today’s Investment U Crib Sheet
- The biggest risk many retired investors face is shortfall risk – that you’ll outlive your savings. And it is quite real. People retiring at 65 face the serious prospect of spending up to three full decades in retirement. Investors using an ultra-conservative approach, with Treasuries, CDs and money markets, are often taking a bigger gamble with their portfolios – and their retirement lifestyle – than they realize. Find out the biggest risk you will face as an investor, and how to protect yourself in Investment U Issue #771, Inflation… The Biggest Risk You Face as an Investor.
- Falling real estate prices, an unrelenting decline in the U.S. dollar, gasoline prices over $4 a gallon, gold passing $800 an ounce, a grinding bear market on Wall Street… How does one survive and prosper during a financial crisis that just won’t go away? Learn more about the Four Lessons you’ll need to profit during a financial crisis in Investment U Issue #776, 4 Investing Lessons: How To Profit During a Financial Crisis.
- Warren Buffett opined that the United States is already in a recession, even if it’s not in the sense that economists would define it. Furthermore, Buffett argues the recession “will be deep and last longer than many think.” However, if you own stocks to meet your long-term financial objectives, stay put. And look for fresh opportunities, too. After all, that’s what Buffett himself is doing… Read about the long-term asset that he’s investing in, in Investment U Issue #801, Warren Buffett Investing: Welcome to the Oracle of Omaha’s “Long, Deep Recession.”
- Stay tuned for tomorrow’s “Buy of the Decade” from Floyd Brown, with opportunities for deep- value investors brought on by the banking crisis.
- Despite What the News Tells You, Crude Oil Prices Set to Fall
- Why I Won’t Pay a Penny Over $70 for Oil
- Green Energy: The Largest Speculative Bubble We’ve Ever Seen
Comments
**By submitting your comment you agree to adhere to our Comment Policy and Privacy Policy.Check out our selection of daily Investment Research:
 |
 |
Alexander Green is the Investment Director of The Oxford Club. A Wall Street veteran, he has over 20 years experience as a research analyst, investment advisor, financial writer and portfolio manager.
