Ben Bernanke and the Economy: How Bernanke Can Keep Stocks Rallying… and Greenspan’s Final Report Card

by Mark Skousen, Chairman, Investment U
Friday, January 20, 2006: Issue #504

Every year, I attend the American Economic Association meetings, where top economists gather to debate the hot issues of the day. This year’s meeting was in Boston. I met with several Nobel Prize winners, and happened to run into New York Times columnist Paul Krugman (a Nobel wannabe). More about this below…

One of the most popular sessions was an assessment of Alan Greenspan. Here was an amazing thing – almost all establishment economists give Greenspan an A or A+. This is unheard of in politics (Fed policy is politics, not just economics). “Greenspan is the greatest central banker ever!” declared Alan Blinder, a Clinton economist.

Greenspan is given high marks because during his 19-year stint (1987-2006), he achieved better than any other central banker the two objectives of the Fed: price stability and full employment. The two recessions we experienced were “mild” and investors made a ton of money on Wall Street. And he handled all the crises well (1987 crash, Asian and Russian crises, Y2K, deflationary threat in the early 2000s, etc.).

As you know, I am less enthusiastic about Greenspan’s record. Before getting into my thoughts on the new Fed Chairman Ben Bernanke and the economy, I’ll tell you why…

Nearly A 20-Year “Roller Coaster” Fed Policy

Under Greenspan’s leadership, inflation and interest rates did decline. However, he changed policies seven times during his tenure, every two to three years, switching from “easy money” to “tight money.”

Consequently, we investors went on a roller coaster ride, experiencing both thrills and upset stomachs along the way. I reproduced the graph showing Fed Funds Target Rates from 1987 to 2006.

Alan Greenspan's Record: Federal Funds Rate, 1987-2006
As to Alan Greenspan’s mistakes, they include:

  • 1994: Fearing inflation, he raised interest rates six times, but no inflation materialized.
  • 1999: He ran scared about Y2K and flooded the U.S. with cash, but had to mop up liquidity in 2000 when the lights and computers stayed on. Greenspan’s own easy-money policies helped create the “irrational exuberance” on Wall Street, and the “slow crash” in the Nasdaq from 2000 to 2003.
  • 2001-2003: After raising rates throughout 2000, he quickly reversed himself and pushed rates down to 1%, fearing a Japanese-style deflation. But the U.S. is no Japan; meanwhile, Wall Street had a field day making billions in closed-end funds and mortgage REITs.
  • 2006: Now in his final days, Greenspan is threatening to create an inverted yield curve to fight inflation, even though inflation is on the decline.
Ben Bernanke: The New Fed Chairman And the Next Crisis for the Economy

I asked Paul Krugman what he thought of the new Fed chairman, Ben Bernanke. “He’s very good,” he said. “But we won’t really know for sure until he faces a real crisis, which could happen at any time.”

“Two years ago,” I said, “you predicted a ‘Great Unraveling’ under President Bush. Yet the economy is booming and the stock market is hitting new highs. Where did you go wrong?”

“What? No, no, my book is not about the economy, it’s about Bush’s politics. It’s spot on.”

Krugman apparently has a short memory. His book is mostly about the economy, and how Bush was destroying it in short order through tax cuts and deficit spending. Then I asked:

“Are you concerned that the price of gold is moving up sharply, and is now approaching $550?”

“Are you kidding?” Krugman said warmly. “Gold is a ‘barbarous relic,’ as Keynes said. It means nothing! I am, however, concerned about a collapse in real estate. It could be a disaster when it happens.”

“Are you selling your home?”

“Well, no.” And he walked away.

Earlier I met up with Gary Becker, a free-market economist from the University of Chicago. Yet he sounded an awful lot like Paul Krugman. “What do you think of Ben Bernanke as the new Fed chairman?” I asked.

“He’s very good.”

“With gold approaching $550 an ounce, is inflation a problem?”

“No, inflation is not a problem,” he said.

“What about the war in Iraq? Isn’t war inflationary?”

“This is a small war. It’s not inflationary.”

Then I talked with Joe Stiglitz, Nobel Prize winner from Columbia, where I taught for the past two years. Stiglitz spoke at a panel on ending global poverty. “Do you think inflation is a problem right now?” I asked.

“No, no problem.”

“Will Bernanke be a good Fed chairman?”

“Yes, he’s excellent.”

“Is there a solution to world poverty?” I asked.

“There’s no magic formula, no magic bullet, I’m afraid.”

The Extra Benefit of Halting the Rate Hikes

Other panelists at the meetings in Boston spent two full hours on their formulas for ending poverty and not once did any of them mention the most successful private-sector method for doing the micro-credit revolution! These panelists included Harvard professor Amartya Sen, also a Nobel laureate, and James Galbraith, son of famed John Kenneth Galbraith.

For those of you unfamiliar with micro-credit, it began several decades ago by Muhammad Yunus, a professor of economics in Bangladesh, who started loaning small amounts of money, from $100 to $300, to small groups of women.

It’s been so successful that the World Bank and several major international banks, such as Citibank and Deutsche Bank, have started their own micro-credit programs. I’ve met Muhammad Yunus, and found him to be a visionary genius. I highly recommend his book, Banker to the Poor.

Stay tuned as I carefully watch the actions of the new Fed chairman, Ben Bernanke. Hopefully, he will abandon Greenspan’s rate-increase policy. If the Fed stops raising rates, stocks will continue to rally. And so will gold. And world poverty will continue to decline. But if the Fed screws things up by raising rates too high, all bets are off.

Good trading,

Mark

Today’s Investment U Crib Sheet

  • The Fed’s actions can be a huge source of profit for quick-minded investors. Ben Bernanke will offer plenty of opportunities for us to profit over the next few years. See Investment U # 481 for more on Greenspan’s record and Bernanke’s new role.
  • Muhammad Yunus’ organization for micro-credit financing is actually owned by the community that it serves 90% of the Grameen Bank’ shares belong to its borrowers! For more information, visit http://www.grameen-info.org. Yunus’ book, Banker to the Poor, can be found on Amazon.
VN:F [1.9.16_1159]
Rating: 0.0/5 (0 votes cast)

Any investment contains risk. Please see our disclaimer.

Comments

By submitting your comment you agree to adhere to our Comment Policy and Privacy Policy.

Search Investment U: